The home theater platform is a rapidly evolving field that offers radical advances every few calendar years. So it’s important to not only invest in solid technology, but to also be able predict technology that’s here to stay against those that are dead on arrival. After all, a home theater system is an expensive investment; a little foresight can go a long way.
The perfect and affordable home theater system essentially boils down to the following logical components: display, source, decoder, output, and control. I’ll now examine each in detail, expressing some of my personal views along the way.
Display
The video display is by far the most important part of the home entertainment system. It’s also one of the most expensive components in the set of required equipment. Fortunately, if your video display requirements are limited to DVD, and you really don’t care to watch the latest episodes of Everybody Loves Raymond in stunning high quality, or you don’t care to connect an X-Box or another console system, then there’s a lot you can do to bring down the price. For instance, for pure DVD watching, a DTV is fine. But you’re looking long-term, it might be worth investing in an HDTV, which supports DVI and HDMI video connectors.
DVD Source
There’s enormous confusion about whether DVD video is progressive or interlaced. Here’s the one true answer from the DVD FAQ:
Progressive-source video is usually encoded on DVD as interlaced field pairs that can be reinterleaved by a progressive player to recreate the original progressive video.
For all intents and purposes, it doesn’t really matter. Basically, the DVD native format is either 480i or 480p, but whether the source is truly interlaced or progressive is a completely irrelevant issue, since the DVD player itself should be true progressive. What is important is that you purchase an anamorphic (16:9) DVD player with component video, or even better, both component and DVI outputs. Recently, HDMI has also been popping up here and there; the only major difference between DVI and HDMI is that HDMI uses a single cable for both digital audio and video. Even the best DVD players these days are only a few hundred dollars, so feel free to splurge a bit in this category.
A Quick Note on Aspect Ratios
Doom9 has some excellent information on this very issue, and explains how a 720×480 DVD video source can be displayed in full screen, letterboxed wide screen, and anamorphic resolutions.
Decoder
As Mike Shea is quick to point out, "there is a much bigger difference in the sound of speakers than there is in the sound of audio electronics." More importantly, the audio quality is a function of the audio impulse response of your room and plays a much stronger role than the number of speakers in your setup. Thus, if your media room is square, make sure that your receiver supports, at mimimum, Dolby Digital and DTS for a 5.1 speaker setup. If your media room is long and rectangular, rather than square, it’s probably best to invest in a 6.1 or 7.1 system, though admittedly most DVD videos are still 5.1, and 6.1 or 7.1 systems have rear mono output. Personally, I’d go with a 6.1 system, especially for smaller rooms. In such case, make sure your receiver supports Dolby Digital EX and DTS-ES. For a good mid-fi solution, Consumer Reports recommends the following:
Output
These are your speakers. If you’re building a new house, your best bet is to let the low-voltage A/V electrician handle this, since they’ll be able to put in the connections in the wall and mount them properly. It’s a pain to do after the house is already built, and this way you can avoid the unsightly wiring.
Control
If your media closet is isolated from the actual theater room, you’ll most likely need some form of wireless IR distribution. For usability and simplicity, it’s important to have a universal remote control. You’ll want a what is termed a learning remote, rather than a preprogrammed remote, for maximum flexibility. There are several excellent options in this area and you can find out more information from Remote Central.
Resources